"Why don't they remake bad movies instead of good ones?"
-Someone I thought was Roger Ebert, but I can't find the quote so I'll just attribute it to everyone on the internet. Everyone.
JJ Abrams directed Star Trek: Into Darkness, which was a terrible movie made worse because it ripped off Star Trek II: The Wrath of Khan. I could go on and on about how terrible a movie it was, but I already did that once. Instead, I'm going to go on and on about The Trek Film Abrams-
Huh? You read the title already? Oh, fine.
While watching the beautiful snooze fest that is Star Trek: The Motion Picture I was struck with an idea; why didn't Abrams rip off this movie instead of Wrath? He could have done wonders with the pacing and soporific nature of that movie.
|And its lack of lens flares.|
But Khan is such a popular character, Abrams wouldn't be able to resist using him. What if he used both! And behold! A new film treatment. We'll call it
Star Trek: Into Light
A giant energy cloud is destroying everything in its path, including planets. It barrels through the Klingon Empire (leaving them weak and vulnerable).
Several admirals want to take the opportunity to invade the Empire, but just as a group of starships embark, they realize the cloud is headed towards Earth. The fleet tries to communicate, but are destroyed, leaving only the Enterprise to save the day. Kirk is given a mission to figure out how to stop it. He takes the Enterprise, which has a new XO he's not comfortable with (although they grow close over time) and Dr. Carolyn Markus, a theoretical physicist (whom he grows incredibly close to).
|If you know what I mean.|
As they approach the cloud, Dr. Carolyn Markus invents a doomsday weapon that could destroy the cloud. The XO attempts to dissuade her, but she insists on presenting it to the captain. The XO, revealing himself to be Khan (in the employ of rogue Admirals who want him to try to direct the cloud at the Romulan Star Empire), picks her up with one hand and throws her against the wall, killing her.
Kirk, devastated, starts a crazed investigation through the ship to find the murderer. His behavior allows Khan (and his compatriots seeded throughout the ship) to mutiny. When they reach the cloud, Khan successfully communicates with it, and the ship is pulled in. He then reveals he isn't planning on directing the cloud to follow Starfleet's whims, but use it to rule the galaxy.
Kirk manages to regain the Enterprise, but not before Khan escapes to the center of V'Ger. Khan is horrified to find that it isn't a massive weapon of war, but a machine with the mind of a child, yearning to merge with its creator to become "something with a soul." Khan tries to merge with V'Ger, to become godlike in power, but V'Ger finds his soul horrifying. V'Ger, its hopes of becoming something more dashed, self-destructs with Khan trapped inside.
The Enterprise barely gets away in time, but an alien probe arrives, following V'Ger's path. They discover it's looking for humpback whales. Kirk is forced to launch Markus's doomsday weapon at it. Meanwhile, the Klingons have killed their own chancellor and framed Kirk for the crime. Fearing their vengeance, he flees with the Enterprise beyond the Great Barrier. There he finds out that God is really the V'Ger/Khan hybrid-
Okay, not my best effort, but better than Into Darkness.